Loading...
Please wait while we prepare your content
Please wait while we prepare your content
Should you install your own security system or hire professionals? Complete cost, reliability, and feature comparison for NJ & PA homeowners.
Quick Answer:
DIY systems work for renters, small apartments, or budget under $500. Professional installation is recommended for homeowners seeking insurance discounts, business owners, or anyone needing reliable protection with local support.
| Feature | DIY Systems | Professional Systems |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | $200-$900 | $500-$6,000 |
| Installation Time | 1-4 hours | 4 hours - 3 days |
| Installation Quality | Your skill level | Licensed technicians |
| Monthly Monitoring | $0-$30 | $30-$60 |
| Insurance Discount | Usually no | Yes, 10-20% typical |
| 5-Year Total Cost | $500-$2,300 | $2,175-$2,850 (after insurance) |
| Net Difference | Only $400-$1,300 more over 5 years for significantly better protection | |
While professional systems cost more upfront, insurance savings of 10-20% ($150-$300/year typical) often offset the extra cost within 2-3 years.
DIY Success Tips: Research sensor placement, test thoroughly, use professional monitoring (not just self-monitoring), check if your DIY system qualifies for insurance discounts.
Professional ROI: Break-even in 2.8 years with insurance savings. After 5 years: $375 net savings vs DIY, plus intangible benefits (professional response, lower false alarms, property value increase).
Best Choice: DIY System
Reasoning: Can't modify rental (adhesive sensors), will move in 1-3 years (take system with them), budget-conscious (lower upfront cost), tech-savvy (comfortable with self-installation).
Recommended: Ring Alarm or SimpliSafe | Cost: $300-$500 upfront, $0-$20/month
Best Choice: Professional System
Reasoning: Own home (permanent installation), want insurance discount (10-20% savings), need reliable protection (kids' safety), prefer professional monitoring (both parents work).
Recommended: Wireless professional system with cellular monitoring | Cost: $1,500 upfront, $40/month | Insurance savings: $225/year = net $255/year
Best Choice: Professional System (Required)
Reasoning: Commercial property (insurance requires professional), need UL listing (code compliance), want access control integration, need after-hours protection.
Recommended: Commercial-grade system with video integration | Cost: $3,000-$8,000 upfront, $75-$150/month | Insurance savings: 15-25% = $750-$1,500/year
Best Choice: Professional System with Medical Alert
Reasoning: Medical emergency capability needed, professional monitoring critical (can't self-respond), local support important (less tech-savvy), insurance discount beneficial (fixed income).
Recommended: Professional system with medical pendant integration | Cost: $1,200 upfront, $50/month | Insurance savings: $150-$300/year
Professional installation with month-to-month monitoring provides the best value when you factor in:
Net cost difference:
Only $400-$1,300 more over 5 years for significantly better protection.
Still not sure? We offer free security assessments with honest recommendations—we'll tell you if DIY makes sense for your situation.