Installing security cameras and surveillance systems requires more than just technical knowledge. Understanding the legal requirements in Pennsylvania and New Jersey is essential to avoid costly lawsuits, criminal penalties, and compliance issues.
After 40 years of installing commercial video surveillance systems and residential security cameras throughout Mercer County NJ and Bucks County PA, we've helped countless businesses and homeowners navigate these complex regulations. This guide covers everything you need to know about surveillance laws in both states.
Legal Disclaimer
This guide provides general information about surveillance laws and is not legal advice. Laws change frequently, and specific situations may have unique requirements. Always consult with a qualified attorney for legal advice regarding your specific circumstances.
In This Guide:
Video Recording Laws (PA vs NJ)
Both Pennsylvania and New Jersey permit video-only recording in most circumstances, but the rules differ between public spaces, private property, and areas with reasonable expectations of privacy.
Pennsylvania
- Video recording in public areas is generally permitted
- Property owners can record on their own premises
- Hidden cameras in private areas are prohibited
- 18 Pa.C.S. 7507.1 prohibits video surveillance of intimate activities
New Jersey
- Video surveillance on private property is permitted
- Public area recording is generally allowed
- N.J.S.A. 2C:14-9 prohibits invasion of privacy recordings
- Recording in areas of expected privacy is criminal
Key Legal Principle: Reasonable Expectation of Privacy
In both states, the "reasonable expectation of privacy" standard determines where recording is prohibited. Areas like bathrooms, locker rooms, changing areas, bedrooms (for non-residents), and hotel rooms are always off-limits. Work areas, retail floors, parking lots, and building entrances typically have no expectation of privacy.
Audio Recording & Consent Requirements
Critical: Both PA and NJ Are Two-Party Consent States
Unlike video recording, audio recording in Pennsylvania and New Jersey requires consent from ALL parties being recorded. Recording conversations without consent is a felony in PA and a serious crime in NJ. This includes security cameras with audio capabilities.
The distinction between video and audio recording is crucial. Many modern video surveillance systems include audio recording capabilities. Using these features without proper consent can result in criminal charges.
| State | Consent Type | Governing Law | Penalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pennsylvania | All-Party Consent (Two-Party) | 18 Pa.C.S. 5703 (Wiretapping Act) | Third-degree felony |
| New Jersey | All-Party Consent (Two-Party) | N.J.S.A. 2A:156A (Wiretap Act) | Third-degree crime |
Audio Recording Best Practices
Workplace Surveillance Regulations
Employers in both PA and NJ have significant latitude to monitor employees in work areas, but must respect privacy in personal spaces. Proper implementation of commercial surveillance systems requires understanding these boundaries.
Generally Permitted Areas
- - Work floors and production areas
- - Reception and lobby areas
- - Hallways and common areas
- - Parking lots and garages
- - Loading docks and warehouses
- - Cash handling areas
- - Server rooms and secure areas
- - Building entrances and exits
Prohibited Areas
- - Restrooms and bathrooms
- - Locker rooms and changing areas
- - Nursing/lactation rooms
- - Private offices (without notice)
- - Union meeting rooms (NJ)
- - Employee break rooms (varies)
- - Personal phone conversations (audio)
- - Medical examination rooms
Employee Notification Requirements
While not always legally required, notifying employees about surveillance is strongly recommended and may be required by company policy or union agreements:
Pennsylvania
- - No specific employee notification law
- - Best practice: Written notice in handbook
- - Audio requires explicit consent
New Jersey
- - Notice recommended for new hires
- - Union workplaces may have requirements
- - Written policies reduce legal exposure
Residential Camera Placement Rules
Homeowners have broad rights to install home security cameras, but must respect neighbors' privacy and avoid recording areas where people have a reasonable expectation of privacy.
Recommended Camera Placements
Safe Locations
- - Front door and entryways
- - Driveway and garage
- - Backyard (your property)
- - Side yards on property line
- - Interior common areas
- - Package delivery areas
Avoid These Views
- - Neighbor's windows (interiors)
- - Neighbor's fenced backyard
- - Neighbor's pool area
- - Children's play areas (others')
- - Bedroom or bathroom windows
- - Private outdoor spaces of others
Handling Neighbor Concerns
If neighbors object to your security cameras, consider these steps:
- 1. Adjust camera angles to minimize views of their property while maintaining security coverage
- 2. Use cameras with privacy masking features to block specific areas from recording
- 3. Document your camera positions and coverage areas in case of legal disputes
- 4. Consult a local attorney if disputes escalate
Signage & Notification Requirements
While not always legally mandated, posting surveillance signage is strongly recommended for both legal protection and crime deterrence.
Legal Protection
Establishes that visitors have no reasonable expectation of privacy in monitored areas
Crime Deterrence
Visible signs can deter criminal activity before it occurs
Evidence Admissibility
Notice can strengthen the admissibility of footage in legal proceedings
Effective Surveillance Signage
Should Include:
- - Clear statement about video surveillance
- - Audio recording notice (if applicable)
- - Visible placement at entrances
- - Contact information for questions
Best Practices:
- - Post at all main entrances
- - Use weather-resistant materials
- - Ensure signs are legible
- - Include in multiple languages if needed
Penalties for Violations
Violating surveillance laws in PA or NJ can result in serious criminal and civil penalties. Understanding these consequences underscores the importance of compliant installation.
Pennsylvania Penalties
| Violation | Classification | Potential Penalty |
|---|---|---|
| Illegal audio recording (wiretapping) | Third-degree felony | Up to 7 years, $15,000 fine |
| Video surveillance of intimate activities | Third-degree felony (18 Pa.C.S. 7507.1) | Up to 7 years, $15,000 fine |
| Invasion of privacy (Peeping Tom) | Second-degree misdemeanor | Up to 2 years, $5,000 fine |
New Jersey Penalties
| Violation | Classification | Potential Penalty |
|---|---|---|
| Illegal wiretapping/audio recording | Third-degree crime | 3-5 years, up to $100,000 fine |
| Invasion of privacy (N.J.S.A. 2C:14-9) | Fourth-degree crime | Up to 18 months, $10,000 fine |
| Surveillance with intent to invade privacy | Third-degree crime | 3-5 years, up to $15,000 fine |
Civil Liability
In addition to criminal penalties, victims of illegal surveillance can pursue civil lawsuits. Damages may include actual damages, emotional distress, punitive damages, and attorney fees. Pennsylvania allows recovery of actual damages plus punitive damages. New Jersey permits actual damages, emotional distress damages, and in some cases, statutory damages.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I record video on my property in NJ without consent?
Yes, in New Jersey you can record video on your own property without consent, as long as cameras are not in areas with reasonable expectations of privacy (bathrooms, changing areas). However, audio recording requires all-party consent.
Is Pennsylvania a one-party or two-party consent state?
Pennsylvania is a two-party (all-party) consent state for audio recording. All parties must consent before recording conversations. Video-only recording has different rules and is generally permitted in areas without privacy expectations.
Do I need to post signs if I have security cameras at my business?
While not always legally required, posting visible signage is strongly recommended. Signs serve as notice, deter crime, and help establish that monitored areas have no expectation of privacy.
Can employers monitor employees with video surveillance in NJ?
Yes, employers can use video surveillance in work areas but not in private spaces like bathrooms or locker rooms. Providing written notice is recommended. Audio surveillance requires consent.
What are the penalties for illegal surveillance?
Penalties are severe. In PA, wiretapping violations are third-degree felonies (up to 7 years, $15,000 fine). In NJ, illegal wiretapping can result in 3-5 years and fines up to $100,000. Civil lawsuits can add additional damages.
Can my neighbor point a security camera at my property?
Generally, neighbors can record areas visible from public spaces, including portions of your property visible from the street. However, cameras cannot view into areas where you have reasonable privacy expectations (inside your home, fenced backyard). You may have legal recourse if privacy is invaded.
Need Help Installing a Compliant Surveillance System?
Our NJ and PA-licensed security experts will design and install a video surveillance system that meets all legal requirements while providing maximum protection for your home or business.
NJ Licensed: Burglar #34BA00089500 | Fire #P00747 | Serving Mercer County NJ & Bucks County PA